25 Jun ALABAMA WORKERS’ RIGHTS AND WRONGFUL TERMINATION
by William Channing Brashaw, Attorney
Many of the jobs in Alabama are what is commonly referred to as “at-will”. Generally, this means that an employer can terminate an employee for “a good reason, a wrong reason, or no reason” as long as the termination is not illegal. There is no statute or legislation that controls the at-will employment doctrine in Alabama, and it is largely controlled by precedents set by court cases. However, like many things in the law, there are state and federal exceptions that work to protect Alabama workers in employment and termination disputes.
In this article, these common exceptions will be explored in some detail, but this will not be a conclusive list for all wrongful termination actions that may be pursued. If you believe you have been wrongfully terminated, it is always best to consult a lawyer to determine whether you have a case. The common exceptions that will be discussed here include Discriminatory Termination, Workers’ Compensation Retaliation, Breach of Contract, Wage and Hour Retaliation, and the Implied Contract exception.
Under various federal laws, it is illegal for employers to terminate an employee because of the employee’s race, color, national origin, sex, pregnancy, religion, age (if the employee is at least 40), disability, citizenship, or genetic information.
Along with these federal laws, Alabama has two laws that protect certain employees: one that protects employees over the age of 40 from discriminatory firing and one that protects disabled persons employed by the state, public school, or any employer who is dependent on public funding.
Typically, the employee must show that the employee’s termination was based solely on their race, color, national origin, sex, pregnancy, religion, age, disability, citizenship, or genetic information. Many times, employers will offer a nondiscriminatory reason as justification for terminating an employee. This makes discriminatory termination cases heavily depend on the evidence to show that the termination was based on a discriminatory purpose.
When an employer wrongfully terminates an employee based on discrimination, the employee may be able to hold the employer responsible and receive damages based on loss of income, loss of benefits, etc. If your claim, though, is based on a federal law, then there are some requirements that must apply to the employer. For example, some claims require the employer must employ over a certain number of employees in order for the employee to have a case.
Each of these discrimination areas involves many moving parts, and The Patton Firm can help you determine whether you have been wrongfully terminated because of discrimination based on the categories above.
Workers’ Compensation Retaliation
In Alabama, an employer cannot fire an employee in retaliation because the employee files a workers’ compensation claim. This law was enacted in 1985 and stands as a significant protection for Alabama workers. Prior to this legislation, workers could be injured and then subsequently fired because they attempted to file a workers’ compensation claim with their employer. These workers would have no recourse or way to hold their employer liable for their conduct.
Now, Alabama workers have a protection in place that sees them through facing an on-the-job injury. However, one caveat is that the employee’s termination must be solely based on the employee’s workers’ compensation claim. If the employer has an independently sufficient basis for terminating the employee, then a wrongful termination claim may not be viable.
If you have recently had an on-the-job injury, attempted to file a workers’ compensation claim with your employer, and was subsequently fired, The Patton Firm can help you determine whether you have a claim.
Breach of Contract
If your employment was granted under a contract, then your employment may not be “at-will”. Depending on the language of the contract, you may be protected from termination, unless the termination is for cause. The employer has to clearly outline in the employment contract what “cause” means in order to terminate the employee without incurring any liability. Also, if your employment contract states that you are to be employed for over a year, Alabama law requires that this contract is written. This type of employment contract is generally referred to as an express contract.
However, all employment contracts do not have to be written. This type of employment contract is commonly referred to as an implied contract. If your employer may make express promises concerning your employment or even acts in a way that appears to promise job security, then an employment contract may be impliedly formed. Like discriminatory termination, implied employment contract cases are largely dependent on the evidence available to show the employer either made these promises or acted in a certain manner.
If an employer wrongfully terminates an employee in violation of one of the employment contract terms or promises, then the employee may have a valid basis to bring a breach of contract action and a wrongful termination action.
The Patton Firm can tell you if you have a claim for wrongful termination under an employment contract or help you determine your rights and responsibilities under your employment contract.
Wage and Hours Retaliation
While Alabama has no state-specific legislation concerning employee’s wages and hours, employers in the state are bound by The Fair Labor Standards Act. This Act ensures that employees are paid at least minimum wage and are paid time and a half (overtime) for any hours worked over 40 per week.
This Act offers protection to workers who attempt to assert their rights under this law and are subsequently terminated. If an employee tries to ensure they are paid properly under this federal law, then the employer may not terminate that employee for exercising their rights in retaliation.
If you were recently terminated after initiating a wage or hour claim against your employer, The Patton Firm can assess whether you have a claim against your employer for wrongful termination.
Implied Contract exception
By far the rarest and narrow exception on this list, the Implied Contracts exception arose from case law in 1987. In Hoffman-La Roche, Inc. v. Campbell, the Alabama Supreme Court held that an employer may be liable for wrongful termination if the employer created an “implied” contract in their personnel policy manual.
Generally, the personnel policy manual must use language that is specific enough to constitute an offer. While it does not have to specifically be an offer for employment, the language must be reasonably read as an offer for employment. This distinction is why this exception is so rarely pursued. Second, the employee must be made aware of this offer, either by the personnel policy manual or by the employer. Lastly, the employee must have accepted the “offer” by beginning or continuing their employment with the employer.
If this can be established, then the employee and employer have an “implied” contract. This “implied” contract may provide the employee with a property interest in their employment which may require the employer to provide a hearing (or another forum for the employee to defend themselves) upon termination. If a hearing (or another forum) is not provided, then the employee may have a claim for wrongful termination.
If any of the abovementioned circumstances have occurred in your recent termination, call The Patton Firm today to see if you have a case. The Patton Firm can help you hold those accountable for violating your employment rights.
Required Disclaimer: No representation is made that the quality of legal services to be provided is greater than the quality of legal services performed by other lawyers.